Make this Jack-O-Lantern Healthy Chicken Pot Pie Recipe for a fun and festive Halloween dinner!
This post may contain affiliate links which means we receive a small commission at
no cost to you when you make a purchase. As an Amazon Associate, I may earn from
qualifying purchases. As an employee of Apogee, any affiliate links from our clients are at 0% commission and two-tiered referrals are at $0.
I love Fall. It is my absolute favorite time of year. Though I don't like COLD weather, I do like nice crisp mornings and snuggling up with Mike in front of the fire in the evenings… following an amazingly tasty meal. This year I am already preparing for the holidays by making recipes that are as healthy as they are delicious – and even sometimes making myself a completely different meal than my family… after all, *I* am on this diet, not them.
Tonight I made my very first ever Chicken Pot Pie – a “healthy-ish” version for me, and a “normal” version for them. To be honest… I could not tell the difference between the two. Both of them were delicious and I am excited to have a new, simple meal to add to my repertoire.
Healthy Halloween Chicken Pot Pie Recipe
Ingredients
- 1 1/2 c 2% milk
- 1 medium onion, , chopped
- 2 rotisserie chicken breasts – cubed
- 3 tbsp flour
- 1 tsp poultry seasoning
- 1/2 tsp pepper
- 1 98 % fat free can cream of chicken soup
- assorted canned vegetables – corn, , lima beans, green beans, carrots, etc
- 2 pie crusts
Instructions
- In a medium sauce pan, mix milk, pepper, flour, and poultry seasoning together over medium heat.
- Stir in chopped onion and cook about 4 minutes or until sauce is thickening and onions are soft.
- Add cream of chicken soup and mix well.
- Slowly add in cooked chicken and vegetables and mix well, lowering heat to low.
- Spoon mixture into empty pie crust. Gently lay second pie crust over top and using a sharp knife, cut out eyes, nose, and mouth and discard cutouts. Use extra dough to make a “stem” if desired.
- Bake 30-35 minutes or until edges are bubbly and crust is browned.
- Serve hot.
Nutrition Information:
Yield: 8 Serving Size: 1Amount Per Serving: Calories: 456 Total Fat: 21g Saturated Fat: 6g Trans Fat: 0g Unsaturated Fat: 12g Cholesterol: 78mg Sodium: 737mg Carbohydrates: 40g Fiber: 4g Sugar: 7g Protein: 29g
My Dad came over tonight and the five of us absolutely LOVED these pies. I do not know that I have ever eaten a chicken pot pie before, but after tasting this one, I know this will be something we make often during the cool nights of Fall and Winter. I wonder if I can cut a turkey into the top crust… hmmm…
Andrew @ Mommy's Busy says
Yum! I LOOOOVE Chicken Pot Pies. My wife made me a healthy one once which was great, but she made the crust herself to be healthier, so it was a bit of a project. I’ll have to share this with her to give a try!
Natalie says
Oh that looks good! I love the Halloween face – who could not resist that awesome pie. Go Chef Lynsey!
Sara Phillips says
YUM!! I think I’d make my own ‘cream of’ soup so that it has less sodium, but YES! I will be making this!
Crystal @ Simply Being Mommy.com says
Love the cut-out on the pie crust. So excited for fall and Halloween. That pot pie looks delish.
Nicole Robinson @TheBookWormMama says
This is too clever, and you’re making me hungry. Must. Pin. Now.
Rebecca Orr says
This looks and sounds delicious. I think my family would enjoy it as well! Definitely bookmarking this! I would attempt the cutout, but I doubt it would be as cute as yours! Lol
Sicorra says
Your pie looks delicious! I have wanted to make one for weeks, and just kept putting it off. Maybe this weekend. I’ll pin this to remind me.
Robin Rue (@massholemommy) says
That is a nice hearty winter dinner idea to make the kids on Halloween night! I love chicken pot pie!
Jeni Hawkins says
WOW – this looks delicious! Perfect for this cooler weather, too. I love the jack-o-lantern face, and the super simple ingredients and instructions. Thank you!
Terri Ramsey Beavers says
I’m loving that pumpkin face on your delicious looking chicken pot pie. I’ll have to try your recipe this week, I think I have all of the ingredients and the kids will love the Halloween spin on it.
Terri says
Chicken pot pie is so good, one of my favourite things to eat, I never knew how to make them but thanks to you
Bri says
This would make a great hearty mid-week dinner. Chicken pot pie is so flavorful and can be enjoyed by all.
Debbie Denny says
I love a good pot pie. Love the halloween twist you did for yours.
Cindy (Prime Beauty) says
My boyfriend love chicken pot pie, this one is so cute!
Elizabeth O. says
I absolutely love chicken pot pie! I don’t have the confidence toake it myself though. Your pot pie looks so delicious!!!
Ryan Escat says
Wow! My family would loved this,a mouth-watering food. Can’t wait to taste this delicious and healthy chicken pot pie.
sojourner says
Well done! What a great meal to prepare for Halloween dinner! Thanks for sharing this. I love the face in the crust.
Ryan Escat says
Wow! My family would loved this too. A mouth-watering food. Cant wait to taste this delicious and healthy chicken pot pie.
victoria says
Sounds good. I love chicken pot pie! I will made this on Friday thanks for this idea.
Nikki says
This is a great idea this coming halloween. My kids would love this.
Travel Blogger says
That is too cute! I’ve been wanting to make pot pies for a while now and havent got around to it.
Mykidsguide says
What a cute pie. I love easy recipes like this. I will bookmark this for later.
Rosey says
What a great idea to make it into a pumpkin. I love it. 🙂
Kendra says
I love homemade chicken pot pie and yours looks too cute! My son would love it!
Deanna says
So cute and it sounds delicious!
Elizabeth O. says
I love that we have healthier versions of our favorite recipes and that makes life so much better! Thanks for sharing this recipe!
dana vento says
Oh how precious your post is! That is such a cute pot pie. Halloween Perfect
Liz Mays says
Oh yum, I love this idea. We’ll need a warm meal like this come Halloween night!
tonygreene113 says
Now that’s a pie worthy of being selfish and stingy with.
victoria says
Your Pie was look delicious and it looks like easy to make. I love to learn a new recipe
Angie Scheie says
How cute is that?! I’ve been wanting to try a chicken pot pie lately, and that face just sold me!!
Patrice says
The pie crust is my favorite delicate feat for the eyes!
Lexie Lane says
You make me hungry right now! I wanna grab this from my screen lol. This is great idea this coming Halloween I’m sure my family would love it. Thanks!
Claudette says
Oh, how I love chicken pot pie! Your recipe is just in time for the cooler climes here! I look forward to trying it.
K. Lee Banks says
I do like chicken pot pie – especially homemade – and this looks yummy!
Eileen Mendoza Loya says
Thanks for the recipe. I would love to make one for my family but my oven broke down and I have to get a new one. Hoping I could replace it before the holidays!
Jessica Cassidy says
Oh my! that looks cute and delish to eat. Thank you for the recipe.
Leigh Powell Hines says
This is so cute. Thank for linking up with us this week.
Ourfamilyworld says
That looks absolutely delicious. I can’t wait to try your recipe.
Sharon G. Cobb says
My father and one of my sons absolutely love pot pies. I’m going to have to try this one!
Faith says
thank you for sharing such a simple healthy meal. I am going to make this tonight!